Why do people blame John Madden for concussion? Videogames

Cover photo of John Madden with soccer ball from Madden 99.

Madden, who appeared on the cover of Madden 99.
Image: EA

Legendary NFL coach John Madden dies at death Tuesday morning, December 28th. Although many took advantage of the case of his death in celebrate this person’s legacy in coaching, broadcast television and video gamesothers used it as an opportunity to urge Madden to play a role in transforming “traumatic brain injury into a video game.” The bribes were incendiary enough to take over sports social networks and websites for days.

The discussion of concussion after John Madden’s death seems to come from a couple of sources. First this is a tweet from freelance journalist Marcy Wheeler, published on the evening of Madden’s death. The tweet reads, “Everyone praising Madden: How many concussions could we have prevented if he hadn’t turned head injuries into a video game?” Wheeler, specializing in civil liberties and national security, lists his football experience and head injuries she played the star monsterback on the puff team and played rugby for six years, during which time she suffered at least one concussion. She also says that a rugby friend died on the field.

Then on Wednesday December 29th, a Dallas College history professor named Dr. Andrew McGregor shared his take on John Madden via his Twitter account: currently set as private… His first tweet read: “I have a lot of opinions about John Madden. Making the Madden video game wasn’t a big deal for the United States. She extolled violence even more and dehumanized black athletes by helping create plantation cosplay that got worse in the fantasy football era. “

A thread, archived in Bar stool Sportultimately boils down to the same sentiment that Wheeler expressed, albeit from a cryptic racist point of view. “The key here,” McGregori writes in a thread, “is the consumption of sport as a distorted reality. Video games dehumanize players, they create superhero fantasy and control and management concepts (reproduced in fantasy sports) where we control and manipulate lineups and players. This is very problematic. “

Dr. McGregor’s tweets have been widely criticized and criticized by fans of both the sport and the video game series. Many objected to him calling the Madden franchise a “digital plantation,” which uses player names and imagery for profit, encouraging fans to ignore the humanity behind them and, by extension, their health. In response to such extreme tweets, many also point to the doctor’s 2017 tweet in which he talks about the game Madden with my brotheras evidence of hypocrisy.

The responses to Marcy Wheeler’s tweet are, as you might guess, pretty harsh. There are tons of embarrassing misogynistic responses, some name-calling, and a few people suggest that EA Madden NFL the series effectively prevented head injuries by giving those interested in sports a safer, more contactless way to play. In response to question“Do you think video games give people concussions,” Wheeler replies. “No. I think video games made fans think that real sports are video games.”

In all fairness, the National Football League doesn’t have the best track record when it comes to the dangers of head injury. In 1994, with a wave of concussion concerns, the NFL formed the Minor Brain Injury Committee, making it head physician with little experience in brain research. In December of that year, NFL Commissioner Paul Tagliablu called concussions “a problem with pack journalism,” suggesting that the media was making too much noise on a relatively minor issue. That same year, Dallas Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman was punched in the head by a knee in a 1993 NFC championship game, a game he still can’t remember, and Chicago Bears quarterback Merrill Hoge retired after a concussion caused him briefly find out his wife and son.

Has a great NFL schedule ongoing concussion at He cleverly deconstructs the league’s long history in an effort to minimize the risk of head injuries as the medical community slowly learns more about the dangers mentioned. According to medical experts, repeated head trauma can lead to chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE, which can cause memory loss, aggressive behavior, motor neuron disease, depression, and suicidal ideation. Doctors examining Andre Waters and Terry Long, two former NFL players who committed suicide, both showed signs of CTE.

The question is whether repeated head injury is dangerous for your health, the answer is given. Yes. Lot. And the NFL has gotten a bit better at it, actively warning about the dangers of concussions and enacting rules to try to reduce the frequency of concussion rather than accidentally brushing it off.

Let’s go back to the autopsy of Marcy Wheeler and Dr. McGregor John Madden. While the NFL’s history of head injuries has been unfortunate, Madden has long talked about the league’s weakness in dealing with concussed players. ESPNTaylor Twellman, in response to comments about Madden being the instigator, tweeted a video of a man commenting on the danger of a concussion back in 1993.

“I think the guy had a concussion or a concussion, then he shouldn’t act anymore,” Madden says in the video. “They always talk about the archaism of boxing, but if a boxer is knocked out, he cannot fight for another month. And sometimes in football we say, “Oh, this guy has a slight concussion, he’ll be back soon.” I don’t know if I ever agreed with that. ”

When it comes to how the EA Madden franchise deals with head injuries and injuries in general, that has slowly changed over the years. In early recordings, players who were injured during the game resulted in an ambulance that comically knocked other players out of the way to get to the injured person. The ambulance was removed after Mad 2001as the NFL found it lauding injury. The kick stick, which allowed players to perform stylish hard grips, was removed shortly after it was introduced in Mad 2005 because the NFL felt it was conducive to violence. There are no more retirement injuries in the game. Concussions have historically been called “head injuries.”

These in-game head injuries meant that the player could be away for a couple of blocks at an older age. Madden games. That changed in Crazy 12, in which players with head injuries are eliminated from the game for the rest of the game, and commentators Gus Johnson and Chris Collinsworth talk about the severity of head injuries when such injuries occur. Head injuries are still relevant to this day, but they are not called concussions. However, this is an order of the NFL, not Madden.

The NFL appears to be keen to prevent the show from getting too violent. But by removing the word concussion from the game discussion, I can understand how anyone would think that it is sending the wrong message to soccer fans.

Yes, football is cruel. People are suffering. Players receive life-changing injuries. The hits are heavy. The possibility of injury was what kept me, a six and a half foot sophomore in high school, from joining the Dunwoody Wildcats. I still play Madden every year, and never once did I have the feeling that breaking my head is normal.

Source link

Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button